Graffiti-style mural on a brick wall featuring three playing cards with state outlines of New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, with the words 'Tri-State Toploaders' and 'Consignment' in bold, colorful text.

Consign with us

Tri-State Toploaders offers a full-service consignment solution for collectors who want maximum exposure, professional handling, and transparent execution—without the headaches of selling on their own.

Whether you’re consigning a single high-end card or an entire collection, we act as your sales partner, managing the entire process from intake to payout while protecting your interests every step of the way.


How do we help you Sell Your cards?

  1. Card Review & Intake
    Cards are reviewed for condition, market demand, and current pricing trends to ensure they are suitable for individual sale rather than lots.

  2. Market-Driven Pricing Strategy
    Each card is priced using real-time market data, recent comps, and demand signals—not arbitrary markups or guesswork.

  3. Professional Listing & Promotion
    Cards are listed on high-visibility platforms under the Tri-State Toploaders brand, leveraging:

    • Strong seller reputation

    • High-traffic listings

    • Strategic auction or buy-it-now formats

  4. Secure Handling & Fulfillment
    We manage packing, shipping, buyer communication, and post-sale logistics—so you don’t have to.

  5. Fast, Transparent Payouts
    Once the transaction clears, proceeds are settled according to the agreed payout schedule with full transparency.

Click Here to Check Out our ebay store with over 15,000+ cards available and more added everyday!

What We Accept

Cards must meet current market standards to be sold individually. Acceptance is based on:

  • Card value and liquidity

  • Market demand

  • Condition and presentation

Cards that do not meet individual sale thresholds may be declined or recommended for alternative sale formats.

Sale Timing & Pricing

Sale timelines vary based on:

  • Market conditions

  • Player performance and trends

  • Auction vs. fixed-price strategy

Pricing and listing strategy are always reviewed and approved before cards are listed.

Fill out our Consignment form and we will reach out here